Disclaimer  This presentation contains forward-looking statements within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, or the Securities Act, and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, or the Exchange Act. Such forward-looking statements include, without limitation, statements concerning our business and growth strategies, investment, financing and leasing activities and trends in our business, including trends in the market for long-term, triple-net leases of freestanding, single-tenant properties. Words such as “expects,” “anticipates,” “intends,” “plans,” “likely,” “will,” “believes,” “seeks,” “estimates,” and variations of such words and similar expressions are intended to identify such forward-looking statements. Such statements involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors which may cause our actual results, performance or achievements to be materially different from the results of operations or plans expressed or implied by such forward-looking statements. Although we believe that the assumptions underlying the forward-looking statements contained herein are reasonable, any of the assumptions could be inaccurate, and therefore such statements included in this presentation may not prove to be accurate. In light of the significant uncertainties inherent in the forward-looking statements included herein, the inclusion of such information should not be regarded as a representation by us or any other person that the results or conditions described in such statements or our objectives and plans will be achieved. Furthermore, actual results may differ materially from those described in the forward-looking statements and may be affected by a variety of risks and factors including, without limitation, the risks described in our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2016 and subsequent quarterly reports on form 10-Q.Forward-looking statements set forth herein speak only as of the date hereof, and we expressly disclaim any obligation or undertaking to update or revise any forward-looking statement contained herein, to reflect any change in our expectations with regard thereto, or any other change in events, conditions or circumstances on which any such statement is based, except to the extent otherwise required by law.THIS PRESENTATION CONTAINS HISTORICAL PERFORMANCE INFORMATION REGARDING STORE CAPITAL, AS WELL AS OTHER COMPANIES PREVIOUSLY MANAGED BY OUR SENIOR EXECUTIVE TEAM. SUCH PAST PERFORMANCE IS NOT A GUARANTEE OF FUTURE RESULTS.This presentation contains references to our copyrights, trademarks and service marks and to those belonging to other entities. Solely for convenience, copyrights, trademarks, trade names and service marks referred to in this presentation may appear without the “© “ or “TM” OR “sm” Symbols, but such references are not intended to indicate, in any way, that we will not assert, to the fullest extent under applicable law, our rights or the rights of the applicable licensor to these copyrights, trademarks, trade names and service marks. We do not intend our use or display of other companies’ trade names, copyrights, trademarks or service marks to imply a relationship with, or endorsement or sponsorship of us by, any other companies.Definitions and footnotes for data provided herein are provided in the appendix section of this presentation. Unless otherwise indicated, data provided herein is dated as of September 30, 2017.  2   

 3  STORE CAPITAL SNAPSHOT  4      FOUNDATIONAL DISTINCTION (How We Uniquely Built STORE)  5   Our Market. Our Investment Strategy. Our Approach to Risk.      Our Capital Structure. Our Internal Growth. Our Leadership.      Our Organizational Structure. Our Governance.    PERFORMANCE (How We Have Performed)  16   Our Portfolio at a Glance. Our Many Key Achievements.      Our High Investment Diversity. Our Contract Quality.      Our Investment Pipeline Activity. Our Growth and Performance.     Our Comparative Stock Return Profile. Our Many Margins of Safety.    APPENDIX (Important Supporting Information)  28   Prior Leadership Investment Performance. Contract Quality Trends.     Peer Group Comparisons. Market Value Added Performance.     Servicing Case Study. Our Approach to Asset Dispositions.     FINANCIAL INFORMATION   40      DEFINITIONS AND FOOTNOTES  48    Table of Contents 

 STORE Capital Snapshot  NYSE: STOR; U.S. PROFIT-CENTER REAL ESTATE ~35-YEAR SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP TRACK RECORD $4.7B EQUITY MARKET CAP; 5.0% DIVIDEND YIELD24% DIVIDEND INCREASE FROM 2014 TO 20171,826 PROPERTIES LEASED TO 382 CUSTOMERS ~75% OF LEASE CONTRACTS INVESTMENT-GRADE QUALITY1 UNIQUE DIRECT ORIGINATION PLATFORM  “STORE Capital is completely distinctive, constructed deliberately on foundational building blocks based upon our decades of highly successful investment experience to make this the absolute best platform we have ever created.” -- Christopher Volk, CEO    4 

 

 Dedicated to net-lease profit-center real estate investments focused on the service sector of the U.S. economyMarket leader in profit-center net-lease solutionsAddressing one of nation’s largest real estate market opportunitiesAmongst fastest-growing real estate net-lease companies1  Why is that so important?Tenants need their profit-center real estate in order to conduct business, making our rent contracts senior to other financial obligations  Which is the unique payment source?Profitability from the operations of each investment  How do STORE properties differ from other commercial real estate assets?Three sources of payment support instead of two  PROPERTY VALUE  CORPORATE CREDIT  UNIT-LEVEL PROFITABILITY  STORE is Single Tenant Operational Real Estate  | foundational distinction |    defining our investment asset class shapes everything we do.  5 

 Broad-Based Market Need  6  Rated  Large  Middle Market  Companies choose to rent because….Leasing real estate replaces both debt and equityLower cost of capitalLongest term means of real estate financeLowest contractual payment obligations  STORE is landlord of choice because….Customer-centric and solutions-orientedAdministrative ease through responsive servicing Development and renovation capabilitiesA focus on corporate flexibility and wealth creation      Our customer relationships begin when we become their landlord; and, if our solutions help our customers succeed, we succeed.  | foundational distinction |    creating stakeholder value begins with meeting broad-based needs and adding value to our customers.  6  >$2.6 TRILLION INVESTABLE REAL ESTATE MARKET    Small Companies        Middle Market Companies  Large Companies  Rated Companies  STORE’s Target market   

    Internal OwnershipDirect calling efforts on thousands of companies and financial sponsors  ~80%    ~20%  B2B Benefits  + Higher Lease Rates+ Lower Real Estate Prices+ Longer Lease Terms+ Smaller Transaction Sizes + Greater Investment Diversity+ Stronger Contracts  Our unique platform has multiple origination channels enabling us to efficiently cover a very large market opportunity.All channels result in a B2B approach.  | foundational distinction |    a hallmark of store is our origination platform, which is essential to superior investment returns and lower investment risk.  “B2B” Origination Platform  Virtual SalesforceTenant introductions through intermediary relationships  = Value for Stockholders  7 

 Investment Portfolio Built “Brick by Brick”  quarterly net new customers and transactions  unprecedented granularity  | foundational distinction |    transaction flow ownership enables organic growth and unparalleled portfolio diversity.  8    customer revenue distribution1  % Of Total Rent & Interest    382 customers | ~ 16 net new customers quarterly 1,826 properties | ~ 73 net new properties quarterly ~ 580 contracts | ~ 30 transactions closed quarterlyAverage transaction size below $9 millionRepeat customers about one-third of new business  <$5M  $5 -$20M  $20 -$50M  $50 -$200M  $200 -$500M  $500M -$1B  >$1B  ~ 70% of customers have revenues over $50 millionMedian tenant revenues ~ $46 millionWeighted average tenant revenues ~$806 millionYear over year tenant revenue growth of 10.8%2  strong tenant revenue profiles 

 Lease Contracts Define Investment Risk  All net-lease real estate investment companies are abstractly an accumulation of contracts that are backed by real estate; and the contracts always govern the investment risk.  | foundational distinction |    our goal is to create investment-grade contracts with every customer.  9 

 Capital Structure Leadership  | foundational distinction |    an effective capital structure must be established at the outset.  10  Effective Liquidity Management$500 million unsecured multi-year revolving credit facilityA+ asset-backed and Baa2/BBB unsecured borrowing optionsVirtually all borrowings are long-term and fixed rate  Effective Asset/Liability ManagementIntelligent, laddered investment-grade borrowingsTarget long-term annual debt maturities below 2.5% of assetsMinimize gap between free cash flow1 and debt maturities  strategic liability management ($MM)  Our structural aim is to have the annual gap between our free cash flow after dividends and our annual debt maturities be 1.5% of assets or less. The smaller the gap, the less interest rate sensitive is our balance sheet.   Median debt maturities  1   4.8% 3.0% 4.2% 3.5% 4.4% 5.1% 5.1% 4.2% 4.4% 4.3%  Avg Rate2 

 Complementary Investment-Grade Debt Options  growing unencumbered asset pool ($MM)  store master funding ($1.5 billion)   S&P rated A+Dedicated asset-backed securities conduit  unsecured term borrowings ($575 million)  | foundational distinction |    multiple complementary investment-grade borrowing sources are integral to a long-term capital markets strategy designed to optimize cost of capital.  Moody’s rated Baa2, stable outlookS&P and Fitch Ratings rated BBB, stable outlook  Q3 2011  Q3 2017  11  Non-recourse with minimal covenantsComplete portfolio management flexibilityEfficient leverage of 70% at time of issuanceBBB rated notes retained for flexibilityEnables superior unsecured debt ratiosProvides leading term borrowing diversity    BBB+/Baa1 Net   STORE Unencumbered Asset     Select Ratios  Lease Average1  Target2  Actual3  Debt/EBITDA  ~5x  ~4x   3.5x  Unencumbered assets/unsecured debt  ~3x  ~3.5x  4.6x  Debt service coverage  ~5x  ~5.5x  7.5x  Cash flow support from encumbered assets  NO  YES    Investment-grade borrowing diversity with resultant improved unsecured credit metrics.  $3.0B$2.5B  $0.4B 

 12  Internal Growth Strategy  Lease Escalation Frequency  % Base Rent and Interest1  Weighted Average Annual Escalation Rate2  Annually  68%  1.8%  Every 5 years  28%  1.8%  Other escalation frequencies  3%  1.7%  Flat  1%  N/A  Total / Weighted Average  100%  1.8%  lease escalations  dividends  Market-leading dividend increases 8.0% in 20157.4% in 20166.9% in 2017Market-leading dividend protection370% payout ratio in 201568% payout ratio in 2016  Annual Lease Escalations  AFFO Per Share Growth  1.00%  1.55%  1.25%  1.93%  1.50%  2.32%  1.80%  2.79%  2.00%  3.09%  +  ReinvestedCash Flows                        65.0%  72.0%  75.0%  80.0%  3.05%  2.38%  2.09%  1.61%          =  EstimatedInternal Growth                                                > 5%  | foundational distinction |    portfolio lease escalations and retained and reinvested cash flows drive significant internal growth.  12  estimated internal growth4    AFFO Payout Ratio    AFFO Per Share Growth 

 13  Unrivaled Leadership  Experienced….Built & managed three net-lease real estate investment companiesInvested over $15 billion in profit-center real estate (9,100+ properties)Consistently outperformed broader REIT market returns over multiple decades*Navigated platforms through multiple economic cycles & interest rate environmentsThought leadership through primary and published research  Groundbreaking….Investment-grade corporate net-lease rating (1995)Net-lease real estate master trust conduit (2005)NYSE-listed public company sales (2001 & 2007)Private institutional investor sponsorship (1999 & 2011)  | foundational distinction |    a progression of innovation and thought leadership over three decades.  13  Senior leaders working together between 10 and 35 years.  1980  Q3 2017  > $15 B  CUMULATIVE ACQUISITIONS 

 77 employees in one office, over 40% of which drive our origination activity and ~25% of which have worked in predecessor companies.  originations  servicing  diligence  finance  risk  RelationshipManagers  Intermediary Managers  Closers  Financial Analysts  Real Estate Analysts  CPAs  Support Professionals  Customer Service  Portfolio Management  Administrative Outsourcing  IT Development Outsourcing  IT Support  Legal Services Outsourcing  Marcomm Support  Separate departments to promote qualityThoughtful compensation plans to promote stakeholder alignmentSelective outsourcing to improve efficiency and scalability Integrated proprietary servicing platform  Efficient and Scalable Platform  | foundational distinction |    highly efficient, scalable platform aligned to core competencies and leadership.  staffing tied to investment activity  staffing tied to investment portfolio size  14 

   Best in Class Corporate Governance  Non-Staggered Board?  Yes  Opt-Out of State Anti-Takeover Provisions¹ and poison pills?  All  Stockholder Rights Plan (SRP)?  No  Investment Committee of Independent Directors  Approves all investments over 1% of assets  Future Implementation of SRP Subject to Stockholder Approval?  Yes  Independent Board, Committees and Chairman  Yes  leading board governance  leading stockholder disclosure  Full tenant credit quality distributionFull contract quality distributionFull tenant size distributionLease contract escalationsProperty appraised replacement costsPortfolio master leasesLeading unit-level performance disclosureProperty sales gain over costsGround lease investmentsNN v. NNN leases   With our leading stockholder disclosure and governance practices, we provide corporate governance that is “best in class” in the net-lease sector.  | foundational distinction |    our transparency reflects our superior tenant reporting requirements and robust it platform.  15 

 Portfolio at a Glance    As of September 30,      2017  2016  Investment property locations  1,826  1,576  States  48  48  Customers  382  337  Industries in which our customers operate  102  100  Proportion of portfolio from direct origination  ~80%  ~75%  Contracts with STORE-preferred terms*1  93%  90%  Weighted average annual lease escalation2  1.8%  1.7%  Weighted average remaining lease contract term  ~14 years  ~14 years  Occupancy3  99.5%  99.2%  Properties not operating but subject to a lease4  14  6  Investment locations subject to a ground lease  19  16  Investment portfolio subject to NNN leases*  98%  97%  Investment portfolio subject to Master Leases*5  87%  80%  Average investment amount / replacement cost (new)6  82%  82%  Locations subject to unit-level financial reporting   97%  97%  Median unit FCCR / 4-wall FCCR7  2.1x / 2.7x  2.1x / 2.6x  Contracts rated investment grade8  ~75%  ~75%    | performance |  16 

 Key Achievements As A Public Company  EXCEPTIONAL PERFORMANCEMore than doubled our pipeline of investment opportunities1 to $12 Billion since IPORaised our dividends to shareholders 24% (6.9% in 2017)Delivered AFFO per share growth of 17% Realized compound annual shareholder returns greater than 16% vs. just over 2.5% for Equity REITsCreated exceptional Market Value Added with our equity valuation exceeding equity cost by 35%2 INVESTMENT SAFETYHave been amongst the industry leaders in dividend protection3Maintained approximately 75% of our lease contracts at investment-grade qualityMaintained a consistent real estate occupancy4 level of 99% or betterMARKET RECOGNITIONGarnered investor interest from well-known investors, including Berkshire Hathaway, a 9.8% shareholderAmongst the highest credit ratings relative to our peer group from all three agencies (BBB, BBB, Baa2)    | performance |  17 

   Diversification Across Industry Groups      Building  % Base Rent and Interest1      # ofProperties  Sq. Ft. (in thousands)  As of September 30,    Customer Industry Groups      2017  2016  Restaurants – Full Service  335  2,348  13.1%  14.1%  Restaurants – Limited Service  392  1,048   7.4%  8.8%  Early Childhood Education  170  1,878   6.8%  7.6%  Movie Theaters  39  1,873   6.3%  7.0%  Health Clubs  67  1,915   6.0%  6.3%  Family Entertainment  25  836  4.2%  4.0%  Automotive Repair and Maintenance  95  460   3.0%  2.1%  Pet Care  102  1,105   3.0%  2.6%  Lumber & Construction Materials Wholesalers  53  2,567  2.1%  1.0%  Career Education  7  584  2.0%  2.3%  Behavioral Health  36  476   1.9%  1.7%  Medical and Dental  29  294   1.5%  0.9%  Elementary and Secondary Schools  6  222   1.5%  1.5%  Equipment Sales and Leasing  18  566   1.5%  1.2%  Wholesale Automobile Auction  6  224   1.1%  0.7%  Consumer Goods Rental  41  554   1.0%  1.0%  All Other Service (22 industry groups)  82  4,405  6.6%  7.0%  Total Service  1,503  21,355  69.0%  69.8%  SERVICE  | performance |  (~69%)  Located near target customers Not readily available onlineBroad array of everyday services  As of September 30, 2017, our portfolio is diversified across 102 different industries in the service, retail and manufacturing sectors of the U.S. economy. We group these industries into 75 different industry groups as shown in the following tables.  18 

   Diversification Across Industry Groups (continued)  19      Building  % Base Rent and Interest1      # ofProperties  Sq. Ft. (in thousands)  As of September 30,    Customer Industry Groups      2017  2016  Furniture  46  2,980  6.3%  3.6%  Farm and Ranch Supply  22  1,859  3.1%  3.2%  Hunting and Fishing  9  758  2.8%  2.3%  Recreational Vehicle Dealers  8  221  1.0%  1.2%  Home Furnishings  5  691  1.0%  1.3%  Electronics and Appliances  7  331  0.8%  0.9%  Used Car Dealers  11  138  0.6%  0.6%  All Other Retail (9 industry groups)  59  2,604  2.0%  2.7%  Total Retail  167  9,582  17.6%  15.8%  Metal Fabrication  47  4,520  3.3%  3.5%  Plastic and Rubber Products  28  3,363  2.8%  2.3%  Medical and Pharmaceutical  6  431  0.9%  1.1%  Electronics Equipment  5  619  0.8%  0.6%  Paper and Packaging  6  969  0.7%  0.6%  Food Processing  4  396  0.6%  2.5%  Chemical Products  7  631  0.5%  0.6%  All Other Manufacturing (14 industry groups)  53  4,702  3.8%  3.2%  Total Manufacturing  156  15,631  13.4%  14.4%            Total Portfolio  1,826  46,568  100.0%  100.0%  RETAIL  MANUFACTURING   | performance |  Primarily located in industrial parksStrategically near customersBroad array of industriesMaking everyday necessities  (~13%)  Located in retail corridorsInternet resistantHigh experiential component   (~18%) 

 20  Top 10 Customers1  AMC Entertainment (NYSE:AMC), is the largest movie exhibition company in the world with approximately 1,000 theatres and 11,000 screens across the globe. The company operates in 44 states and approximately 52% of the U.S. population lives within 10 miles of an AMC theater.  Cadence Education is a Morgan Stanley Global PE owned company and is one of the premier early childhood educators in the U.S. The Company’s national platform of more than 150 schools has the capacity to serve more than 20,000 students across 20 states.   Mills Fleet Farm is a full-service merchant with more than 35 locations in four mid-western states, offering a broad assortment of goods from hunting gear to lawn, garden and farm supplies. In 2016 Mills was purchased by the PE firm KKR & Co.  RMH Franchise Holdings is the second largest Applebee’s franchisee, operating 170+ units in 15 states. The company is a top 100 multi-unit franchisee company in the United States and was formed in 2012 with the backing of PE firms including ACON Investments.  O'Charley's operates over 300 casual dining restaurants, over 200 of which are branded as O’Charley’s. O'Charley's is a wholly owned subsidiary of American Blue Ribbon Holdings, which is majority owned by Fidelity National Financial.  % Base Rent and Interest2  2.9%  2.8%  2.4%  2.0%  2.0%  1.7%  1.4%  1.2%  1.2%  1.1%    | performance |  18.7%  Total Top 10 Customers  Art Van Furniture is the Midwest’s largest furniture retailer and America’s largest independent furniture retailer. Founded in 1959, the company operates more than 100 stores throughout five Midwestern states, including Art Van Furniture franchise locations as well as Art Van mattress and flooring stores.  Automotive Remarketing Group, dba America’s Auto Auction is one of the fastest growing auto auction companies in the nation. Today the company operates 21 successful auction locations nationwide. The Company is a wholesale auto auction company offering a full spectrum of remarketing services for both buyers and sellers of used vehicles.  Stratford School, founded in 1999, is the premier US-based private education platform combining great academic outcomes and a strong base of existing campuses of elementary and middle schools. Grown organically to over 6,000 students across 22 campuses throughout California, including five opened in the last two years, with a strong foundation to drive continued growth.  # ofProperties  17  9  15  6  32  37  33  30  4  6  189  Bass Pro Group operates retail locations under the Bass Pro Shops and Cabela’s monikers, offering outdoor gear and apparel in an immersive setting. These two iconic brands, combined, operate more than 180 retail and marine centers. Both concepts are market leaders and highly respected within their respective niche of outdoor products.  U.S. LBM Holdings, founded in 2009, is a collection of leading building material distributors across 29 states with more than 230 locations. The company serves as a critical link in the building materials supply chain, supplying more than 60,000 stock keeping units (“SKUs”) for custom homebuilders and specialty contractors. 

 Diversification Across Geographies1    | performance |  21  OCCUPANCY2 

 ~75% of Contracts Investment-Grade in Quality  Because we invest in profit-center real estate, our contracts almost always have less investment risk than the credit risk of our tenants. In addition, the STORE Score, being purely quantitative, is a base risk score that often understates contract quality.    | performance |  Moody’s RiskCalc (EDF) STORE Score 1        22  CONTRACTS RATED INVESTMENT GRADE (3-MO. AVERAGE)  MEDIAN UNIT-LEVEL FIXED CHARGE COVERAGE    Median EDF  MedianSTORE Score 

 23  Investment Pipeline Activity  Total Pipeline1  Deals Reviewed1  Cumulative Annual Acquisitions ($MM)      2012    2013  2014   2015  2016    2017  PIPELINE VELOCITY ($B)  PIPELINE SECTOR DISTRIBUTION AS OF 9/30/17  87% of our investments and 86% of our pipeline are customer facing industries with emphasis on the service sector.    | performance |  S|T|O|R|E’s Pipeline remains Robust and Diverse 

 24    NOI, AFFO AND NET INCOME ($MM)2   Growth and Performance    | performance |        PER SHARE ANNUAL GROWTH   NET INCOME:16.4%  DIVIDENDS:8.6%  AFFO:10.1%  Average Annual Growth Rate  ACQUISITION AND DISPOSITION VOLUME ($MM)1  GROSS RATE OF RETURN 3  5.6%  5.3%  5.4%  5.6%  4.1%  4.7%  4.4%  4.1%  9.7%  8.3%  8.1%  7.9%  8.0%  10.0%  9.8%  9.7%  9.6%  7.8%  3.6% 

 Total Return Built on Both Yield & Growth    | performance |  25  500 companies  21 companies(4%)  5 companies(1%)  Only 1% of companies in the S&P 500 have STORE’s combination of dividend yield and EPS growth offering a superior investment opportunity.  240% Price-to-Total Return Discount  S&P 500 INDEX2            S&P Multiple    26.6 x         Dividend Yield    2.0%   LTM EPS Growth    9.0%  Total Return    11.0%  PEGY     2.4 x        STORE CAPITAL            AFFO Multiple    14.5 x         Dividend Yield    5.0%   LTM AFFO Growth Rate    8.9%  Total Return    13.9%  STOR PEGY     1.0 x   

 Margins of Safety  Portfolio QualityApproximately 75% investment-gradeMaster leases 87% of the time97% property-level financial statementsMarket-leading investment diversityInvestments average 82% of replacement costInvestment yields above NAV auction yields  Financial StrengthA highly protected dividendMarket-leading internal growth1 Multiple investment-grade borrowing optionsConservative leverage and flexible balance sheet    | performance |  26 

 Distinction  market-leading investment approach in underserved market exceeding $2.6 trillion  1.  predominantly investment-grade quality net-lease contract portfolio  2.  market-leading diversified capital markets strategy  3.  secure dividends and dividend growth  4.  margins of safety for our shareholders in everything we do  5.  leadership team with 35-year history and a multiple-decade record of outperformance*  6.    | performance |  27 

     Appendix 

    FFCA (NYSE: FFA) 1994 - 2001  Spirit Finance (NYSE: SFC) 2003 - 2007  STORE Holding (Oaktree) 2011 - 2016  Management Team Performance    | appendix – historical performance |  Management has unparalleled expertise in creating successful STORE investment platforms in a variety of market environments.  29  $4.9 billion Invested Average Cap Rate 10.3%Average 10-year US Treasury 6.2%Asset-Backed and Unsecured DebtRated BBB by S&P, Baa2 by Moody’sAverage Occupancy 98+%Sold to GE Capital  $3.5 billion InvestedAverage Cap Rate 8.7%Average 10-year US Treasury 4.4%Asset-Backed DebtNo corporate credit ratingAverage Occupancy 99+%Sold to consortium of investors  $4.4 billion InvestedAverage Cap Rate 8.3%Average 10-year US Treasury 2.3%Asset-Backed and Unsecured DebtRated BBB- by S&P, BBB- by FitchAverage Occupancy 99+%Founding shareholders sold shares in public market 

      | appendix – historical performance |  30  1994  2016  Stable and Attractive Lease Rates and Risk-Adjusted Returns  Low lease rate volatility and strong investment spreads have resulted in superior risk-adjusted returns.  S|T|O|R|E and predecessors’ average Lease Rates vs. 10-Year Treasuries  Excess Return relative to Market Risk 2 

   ¹ Information based on YTD 2Q 2017 reported results. For companies where the year-to-date lease rate on new acquisitions is not disclosed, the formula assumes a lease rate of 7.0%. Same Store NOI growth used as a proxy for contract lease escalator where the latter is not disclosed. For companies where neither is disclosed, the formula assumes a lease escalator of 1.50%. EBITDA margin is based on revenue less reimbursed property expenses and straight-line rent. Marginal interest rate is based on the current spread on unsecured debt outstanding over the 10 year treasury.     | appendix - returns |  Our elevated equity return on new investments is a principle driver of our margins of safety and contributes to superior equity value creation ability.  Marginal Equity Returns on Net Lease Real Estate Investments  31  Marginal Equity RETURNS1  ((lease rate + lease escalators) x EBITDA margin - (marginal interest rate x % funded with debt))  % funded with equity  ROE computed on new investments using the V-Formula  

   | appendix - returns |  32  ADCEPRNNNSRCO  ADCONNNEPRSRC  SRCEPRNNNADCO  GROSS Cap Rate SPREAD over the cost of debt1  MVA Growth Rate2  CURRENT AFFO Multiple3  S|T|O|R|E  S|T|O|R|E  S|T|O|R|E  Elevated gross cap rates and EBITDA margins have contributed to higher equity rates of return, leading to a higher spread between shareholder historic cost and market valuation, or Market Value Added (MVA).  Comparative Value Creation STORE vs. Peers  ¹ For the YTD period ended June 30, 2017. Gross cap is Initial cap rate on new acquisitions plus contract bumps. For companies where the year-to-date lease rate on new acquisitions is not disclosed, the formula assumes a lease rate of 7.0%. Same Store NOI growth used as a proxy for contract lease escalator where the latter is not disclosed. For companies where neither is disclosed, the formula assumes a lease escalator of 1.50%. Cost of debt is the current spread on unsecured debt outstanding over the 10 year treasury.2 Calculated using the formula: [market capitalization / computed equity cost]^(1 / weighted average age of equity) 3 Calculated as of October 16, 2017   

 Consistent Contract Quality   STRONG CONTRACT STABILITY ACROSS STORE’S PORTFOLIO OVER TIME   33  Investment grade contracts averaging ~75% of STORE’s rent over prior three years.  Tenant Rating vs. Contract Rating (Cumulative)    Strong contracts create a margin of safety relative to corporate credit risk.  Contract Ratings  | appendix – portfolio| 

   Most Diversified Tenant Base  Source: Latest publicly available financial information as of June 30, 2017. ¹ Includes: Agree Realty Corporation; EPR Properties; Lexington Realty Trust; Spirit Realty Capital, Inc.; VEREIT, Inc.; and W. P. Carey Inc.  (weighted average lease term in years)  Longest Lease Term  Lowest Near-Term Renewal Exposure  (% top 5 tenants, based on current annual rent)  (% expirations by period, based on current annual rent)    Our net-lease portfolio has long contract terms and very high tenant diversification.  High Quality Portfolio  34  | appendix – portfolio| 

 ebitda margin1    Average Lease escalator2  Source: Latest publicly available quarterly financial statements as of June 30, 2017. ¹ Represents Adjusted EBITDA to Total Adjusted Revenue.2 See page 50 (page 16, footnote 2) for description of STORE’s weighted average annual lease escalation. Realty Income and VEREIT data represents projected same store sales based on midpoint of 2017 company estimates.    (based on Q2 2017 financials)  affo payout ratio  (based on Q2 2017 financials)    Stable and Growing Cash Flow  Our lease contracts and well-protected dividends provide cash flow growth and stability.    35  (based on Q2 2017 financials)  | appendix – portfolio| 

 Case Study: National Restaurant Chain Bankruptcy  Investment Overview  National restaurant chain that operated over 200 stores.At the time of STORE’s investment: Moody’s RiskCalc EDF – B3Acquired two properties subject to existing individual leases as part of a diversified portfolio acquisition.STORE proactively sold one of the locations due to underperformance for a 14% gain on investmentSubsequently acquired eight properties in a direct sale leaseback with the company.15-year master lease with annual rent escalations of 2%Average sales of almost $3.0 million and a master lease FCC of 2.3x (STORE Score – Baa3)    Investment Risk is Governed by the Quality of the Lease Contract  Bankruptcy & Result  Tenant filed for bankruptcy protection.Tenant exited bankruptcy after a few months.Closed 34 storesNegotiated $4.0 million in rent savings Converted $300 million in debt to equity STORE’s master lease was assumed in bankruptcy.No modification to master leaseLease payments brought current.Limited rent reduction (13%) on the individual lease. 100% recovery on the eight unit master leaseFollowing the restructure, STORE’s blended cap rate for this investment was at least 200 basis points over market cap rates for national casual dining restaurant chains.  Tenant Moody’s RiskCalc EDF  MasterLeaseSTOREScore  36  IndividualLeaseSTOREScore  | appendix – portfolio| 

 2017 Dispositions    active portfolio management is a strong complement to our property management activity to minimize portfolio investment risk  During the First Three Quarters of 2017, STORE divested $210MM in real estate and generated net cash proceeds over cost of $14MM    > 150 bps spread over the market    Represents a 93% recovery*  PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT ($MM)*  PROPERTY MANAGEMENT ($MM)*    > 70 bps spread over the market  $99  $82  $44  $41  $81  $87  37  | appendix – portfolio| 

 38  Executive Management Team    | appendix – STORE leadership|  MARY FEDEWAChief Operating Officer & DirectorCo-Founder; Chief Operating Officer, Assistant Secretary and Assistant Treasurer; Director since August 2016Former Managing Director of Acquisitions at Spirit; former Senior Vice President of GE Franchise Finance (successor company to FFCA)>20 years of experience in a broad range of financial servicesRecognized as a Woman of Influence in 2016 by Real Estate Forum magazine  CHRISTOPHER H. VOLKPresident, CEO & DirectorCo-Founder; CEO and Director since Company’s inception in May 2011Former Co-Founder, CEO and Director of Spirit Finance Corporation (“Spirit”); former President and Director of Franchise Finance Corporation of America (“FFCA”)>30 years of experience in structuring, managing and financing commercial real estate companiesLed largest ever real estate limited partnership roll-up transaction of its time in 1994 in formation of FFCA; oversaw issuance of FFCA's unsecured debt rating in 1995, the first unsecured debt rating ever issued to a net-lease REIT; led creation of first commercial real estate master trust debt conduit in the United States designed to finance net-lease assets in 2005 at Spirit   CATHERINE LONGChief Financial Officer, EVP & TreasurerCo-Founder; Executive Vice President – CFO, Treasurer and Assistant Secretary since Company’s inceptionFormer CFO and Treasurer of Spirit; former Principal Accounting Offer of FFCA>30 years of accounting, operating and financial management expertise Named CFO of the Year in 2008 by Arizona chapter of Financial Executives International  CHRISTOPHER K. BURBACHEVP – UnderwritingExecutive Vice President – Underwriting since February 2012Former Vice President of Investment Management at Spirit; former CEO of VM ManagementBroad range of experience in credit, underwriting and financial analysis  MICHAEL T. BENNETTEVP – General Counsel, Chief Compliance Officer & SecretaryCo-Founder; Executive Vice President—General Counsel, Chief Compliance Officer, Corporate Secretary and Assistant TreasurerFormer Senior Vice President of Spirit; former General Counsel of Farmer Mac (NYSE:AGM)>30 years of legal, transactional and operational experience in real estate and finance industriesNamed best in-house attorney at the Arizona Corporate Counsel Awards in 2017 by Az Business magazine 

 39  Board of Directors    MORTON H. FLEISCHERChairmanChairman since inception in May 2011. Former Co-Founder and Chairman of Spirit and FFCA  MARY FEDEWAChief Operating Officer & DirectorCo-Founder of S|T|O|R|E; COO since September 2017 (previously EVP – Acquisitions since inception in May 2011); Director since 2016  William F. HippDirectorDirector since 2016. Former head of real estate for Key Bank, BankBoston and FleetBoston with over 35 years in commercial banking  Einar A. SeadlerDirectorDirector since 2016. Founder and President of EAS Advisors LLC; Former Managing Director of Accenture Strategy  Joseph M. DonovanDirectorDirector since 2014. Chairman of Fly Leasing Limited (NYSE: FLY)  Mark N. SklarDirectorDirector since August 2016. Founding partner and Director of DMB and its affiliated companies  Quentin P. Smith, JrDirectorDirector since 2014. Founder and President of Cadre Business Advisors LLC; Director of Banner Health System  CHRISTOPHER H. VOLKChief Executive Officer & DirectorCo-Founder of S|T|O|R|E; CEO and Director since inception in May 2011. Former Co-Founder, CEO and Director of Spirit and President and Director of FFCA   | appendix – STORE leadership|  Catherine D. riceDirectorDirector since October 2017. Former Senior Managing Director and CFO of W.P. Carey; Partner at Parmenter Realty Partners  

     Financial Information 

 41    Condensed Consolidated Statements of Income    Three Months Ended            Nine Months Ended              September 30,            September 30,            $ thousands, except share and per share data  2017      2016        2017      2016     Revenues:  (unaudited)            (unaudited)             Rental revenues    $ 104,039       $ 91,759       $ 314,093       $ 259,666      Interest income on loans and direct financing receivables    5,502       5,023       16,729       14,101      Other income    1,003       216       1,901       435      Total revenues    110,544       96,998       332,723       274,202      Expenses:                           Interest    31,379       27,121       91,938       76,427      Transaction costs    -       155       -       490      Property costs    1,335       807       3,272       2,519      General and administrative    10,255       8,104       29,787       25,240      Selling stockholder costs    -       -       -       800      Depreciation and amortization    37,589       31,112       110,200       86,626      Provision for impairment of real estate    7,670       -       11,940       -      Total expenses    88,228       67,299       247,137       192,102      Income from operations before income taxes    22,316       29,699       85,586       82,100      Income tax expense    81       89       334       248      Income before gain on dispositions of real estate    22,235       29,610       85,252       81,852      Gain on dispositions of real estate, net of tax    6,345       6,733      35,778       9,533     Net income    $ 28,580       $ 36,343       $ 121,030       $ 91,385                                Net income per share of common stock - basic and diluted    $ 0.15       $ 0.24       $ 0.69      $ 0.62                                Dividends declared per common share    $ 0.31       $ 0.29       $ 0.89       $ 0.83                                Weighted average common shares outstanding – basic    189,656,095      153,143,726       174,481,758       146,491,617      – diluted    190,043,107      153,462,048       174,481,758       146,747,194     | appendix - financial | 

   Condensed Consolidated Balance Sheets  $ thousands, except share and per share data    September 30, 2017        December 31, 2016            (unaudited)        (audited)    Assets                  Investments:                   Real estate investments:                   Land and improvements      $ 1,788,412         $ 1,536,178      Buildings and improvements      3,763,510         3,226,791      Intangible lease assets      88,671         92,337      Total real estate investments      5,640,593         4,855,306      Less accumulated depreciation and amortization      (393,037  )      (298,984  )        5,247,556         4,556,322      Loans and direct financing receivables      273,265         269,210     Net investments      5,520,821         4,825,532     Cash and cash equivalents      34,986         54,200     Other assets, net      58,910         61,936     Total assets      $ 5,614,717         $ 4,941,668                       Liabilities and stockholders' equity                  Liabilities:                   Credit facility       $ 82,000          $ 48,000      Unsecured notes and term loans payable, net      570,376         470,190      Non-recourse debt obligations of consolidated special purpose entities, net      1,741,343         1,833,481      Dividends payable      58,904         46,209      Accrued expenses, deferred revenue and other liabilities      68,888         60,533     Total liabilities      2,521,511         2,458,413                       Stockholders' equity:                   Common stock, $0.01 par value per share, 375,000,000 shares authorized, 190,013,411                   and 159,341,955 shares issued and outstanding, respectively      1,900         1,593      Capital in excess of par      3,284,353         2,631,845      Distributions in excess of retained earnings      (194,671  )      (151,592  )   Accumulated other comprehensive income      1,624         1,409      Total stockholders' equity      3,093,206         2,483,255     Total liabilities and stockholders' equity      $ 5,614,717         $ 4,941,668     42  | appendix - financial | 

   Funds From Operations and Adjusted Funds from Operations1      Three Months Ended                Nine Months Ended                   September 30,                September 30,                $ thousands, except per share data  2017        2016        2017        2016           (unaudited)                (unaudited)                 NET INCOME    $ 28,580        $ 36,343         $ 121,030        $ 91,385         Depreciation and amortization of real estate assets    37,397         30,956          109,698         86,236         Provision for impairment of real estate    7,670         -          11,940         -         Gain on dispositions of real estate, net of tax    (6,345  )      (6,733  )      (35,778  )      (9,533  )     FUNDS FROM OPERATIONS (FFO)    $ 67,302        $ 60,566          $ 206,890        $ 168,088         Adjustments:                                     Straight-line rental revenue, net    (1,185  )      (963  )      (2,962  )      (2,548  )     Transaction costs    -        155         -         490         Amortization of:                                     Equity-based compensation    2,012         1,796          5,880         5,219         Deferred financing costs and other noncash interest expense2    4,037         1,831          8,127         5,318         Lease-related intangibles and costs3    5,025         418          5,642         1,321         Accrued severance costs    296        -        296        -       Selling stockholder costs    -         -          -         800         ADJUSTED FUNDS FROM OPERATIONS (AFFO)    $ 77,487        $ 63,803          $ 223,873        $ 178,688                                              Net Income per share of common stock - basic and diluted4    $ 0.15        $ 0.24          $ 0.69         $ 0.62                                              FFO per share of common stock – basic and diluted4    $ 0.35        $ 0.39          $ 1.18         $ 1.14                                              AFFO per share of common stock – basic4 – diluted4    $ 0.41$ 0.41        $ 0.42$ 0.41          $ 1.28$ 1.28        $ 1.22$ 1.21        43  | appendix - financial | 

 GAAP Reconciliations: Net Income to FFO and AFFO    44    Year Ended        December 31,       $ millions  2014  2015  2016   NET INCOME  $ 48.1  $ 83.8  $ 123.3   Depreciation and amortization of real estate assets  56.7   88.3   119.1    Provision for impairment of real estate  -   1.0   1.7    Gain on dispositions of real estate, net of tax  (5.5)   (1.3)   (13.2)   FUNDS FROM OPERATIONS (FFO)  $ 99.4  $ 171.7  $ 230.9   Adjustments:         Straight-line rental revenue, net  (2.4)  (2.0)  (2.3)   Transaction costs  2.8   1.2   0.5    Amortization of:         Equity-based compensation  2.3   4.7   7.0    Deferred financing costs and other noncash interest expense  7.1   6.5   7.3    Lease-related intangibles and costs  0.7   1.4   1.7    Selling stockholder costs  -   -   0.8    ADJUSTED FUNDS FROM OPERATIONS (AFFO)  $ 109.9  $ 183.5  $ 245.8  | appendix - financial | 

 GAAP Reconciliations: Net Income to NOI    45    Year Ended        Nine Months Ended      December 31,        September 30,     $ millions  2014  2015  2016    2016  2017   NET INCOME  $48.1  $83.8  $123.3    $91.4  $121.0   Less: Gain on dispositions of real estate, net of tax  (4.5)  (1.3)  (13.2)    (9.5)  (35.8)   Less: Income from discontinued operations, net of tax  (1.1)  -   -     -   -    INCOME FROM CONTINUING OPERATIONS  $42.5  $82.4  $110.1    $81.9  $85.3   Adjustments:               Income tax expense  0.2   0.3   0.4     0.2   0.3    Depreciation and amortization  57.0   88.6   119.6     86.6   110.2    General and administrative  19.5   28.0   34.0     25.2   29.8    Transaction costs  2.8   1.2   0.5     0.5   -    Interest  68.0   81.8   105.2     76.4   91.9    Selling Stockholder costs  -   -   0.8     0.8   -    Provision for impairment of real estate  -   1.0   1.7     -   11.9    NET OPERATING INCOME  $190.0  $283.2  $372.3    $271.7  $329.5  | appendix - financial | 

 GAAP Reconciliations: Debt to Adjusted Debt    46   $ millions  As of        September 30, 2017       Credit facility     $ 82.0     Unsecured notes and term loans payable, net    570.4     Non-recourse debt obligations of consolidated special purpose entities, net    1,741.3     TOTAL DEBT    $ 2,393.7     Adjustments:         Unamortized net debt discount    0.4     Unamortized deferred financing costs    32.7     Cash and cash equivalents    (35.0  )   Restricted cash deposits held for the benefit of lenders    (14.4  )   ADJUSTED DEBT    $ 2,377.4    | appendix - financial | 

 GAAP Reconciliations: Net Income to Adjusted EBITDA    47   $ millions  Three Months Ended        September 30, 2017       NET INCOME    $ 28.6     Adjustments:         Interest    31.4     Depreciation and amortization    37.6     Income tax expense    0.1     EBITDA    97.6     Adjustments:         Provision for impairment of real estate    7.6     Gain on dispositions of real estate, net of tax    (6.3  )   ADJUSTED EBITDA    $ 99.0     Estimated adjustment to Adjusted EBITDA if all real estate acquisitions and dispositions for         the quarter ended September 30, 2017 had occurred as of July 1, 2017    4.3     ADJUSTED EBITDA – CURRENT ESTIMATED RUN RATE    $ 103.2             ANNUALIZED ADJUSTED EBITDA    $ 395.8     ANNUALIZED ADJUSTED EBITDA – CURRENT ESTIMATED RUN RATE    $ 413.0             ADJUSTED DEBT / ANNUALIZED ADJUSTED EBITDA    6.0x     ADJUSTED DEBT/ ANNUALIZED ADJUSTED EBITDA – CURRENT ESTIMATED RUN RATE    5.8x    | appendix - financial | 

 48    Supplemental Reporting Measures  Funds from Operations, or FFO, and Adjusted Funds from Operations, or AFFO Our reported results are presented in accordance with U.S. generally accepted accounting principles, or GAAP. We also disclose Funds from Operations, or FFO, and Adjusted Funds from Operations, or AFFO, both of which are non‑GAAP measures. We believe these two non‑GAAP financial measures are useful to investors because they are widely accepted industry measures used by analysts and investors to compare the operating performance of REITs. FFO and AFFO do not represent cash generated from operating activities and are not necessarily indicative of cash available to fund cash requirements; accordingly, they should not be considered alternatives to net income as a performance measure or to cash flows from operations as reported on a statement of cash flows as a liquidity measure and should be considered in addition to, and not in lieu of, GAAP financial measures. We compute FFO in accordance with the definition adopted by the Board of Governors of the National Association of Real Estate Investment Trusts, or NAREIT. NAREIT defines FFO as GAAP net income, excluding gains (or losses) from extraordinary items and sales of depreciable property, real estate impairment losses and depreciation and amortization expense from real estate assets, including the pro rata share of such adjustments of unconsolidated subsidiaries. To derive AFFO, we modify the NAREIT computation of FFO to include other adjustments to GAAP net income related to certain non‑cash revenues and expenses that have no impact on our long-term operating performance, such as straight‑line rents, amortization of deferred financing costs and stock‑based compensation. In addition, in deriving AFFO, we exclude certain other costs not related to ongoing operations, such as the amortization of lease-related intangibles and, historically, transaction costs associated with acquiring real estate subject to existing leases.  FFO is used by management, investors and analysts to facilitate meaningful comparisons of operating performance between periods and among our peers primarily because it excludes the effect of real estate depreciation and amortization and net gains on sales, which are based on historical costs and implicitly assume that the value of real estate diminishes predictably over time, rather than fluctuating based on existing market conditions. Management believes that AFFO provides more useful information to investors and analysts because it modifies FFO to exclude certain additional non-cash revenues and expenses such as straight‑line rents, amortization of deferred financing costs and stock‑based compensation as such items may cause short-term fluctuations in net income but have no impact on long-term operating performance. Additionally, in deriving AFFO, we exclude certain other costs, such as the amortization of lease-related intangibles and, historically, transaction costs associated with acquiring real estate subject to existing leases. We believe that these costs are not an ongoing cost of the portfolio in place at the end of each reporting period and, for these reasons, we add back the portion expensed when computing AFFO. Similarly, in 2016 we excluded the offering expenses incurred on behalf of our selling stockholder, STORE Holding, when it exited all of its holdings of STORE Capital common stock, as those costs are not related to our ongoing operations. As a result, we believe AFFO to be a more meaningful measurement of ongoing performance that allows for greater performance comparability. Therefore, we disclose both FFO and AFFO and reconcile them to the most appropriate GAAP performance metric, which is net income. STORE Capital’s FFO and AFFO may not be comparable to similarly titled measures employed by other companies.   | appendix | 

 49    Supplemental Reporting Measures  We believe that presenting supplemental reporting measures, or non-GAAP measures, such as EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDA, is useful to investors and analysts because it provides important information concerning our operating performance exclusive of certain non-cash and other costs. These non-GAAP measures have limitations as they do not include all items of income and expense that affect operations. Accordingly, they should not be considered alternatives to net income as a performance measure and should be considered in addition to, and not in lieu of, GAAP financial measures. Our presentation of such non-GAAP measures may not be comparable to similarly titled measures employed by other companies. The following is a summary of the primary inputs into our presentation of these measures.  EBITDA, Adjusted EBITDA, Annualized Adjusted EBITDA and Adjusted DebtEBITDA represents earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization.Adjusted EBITDA represents EBITDA modified to include other adjustments to GAAP net income for transaction costs, non-cash impairment charges, gains/losses on dispositions of real estate and certain other expenses not related to our ongoing operations.Annualized Adjusted EBITDA is calculated by multiplying Adjusted EBITDA for the quarter by four. Annualized Adjusted EBITDA – Current Estimated Run Rate is calculated based on an estimated Adjusted EBITDA as if all leases and loans in place as of September 30, 2017 had been in place as of July 1, 2017; then annualizing the Adjusted EBITDA for the quarter by multiplying it by four. You should not unduly rely on this metric as it is based on several assumptions and estimates that may prove to be inaccurate. Our actual reported Adjusted EBITDA for future periods may be significantly less than that implied by our reported Annualized Adjusted EBITDA – Current Estimated Run Rate for a variety of reasons.  Adjusted Debt represents our outstanding debt obligations excluding unamortized deferred financing costs and net debt premium, further reduced for cash and cash equivalents and restricted cash deposits held for the benefit of lenders. We believe excluding unamortized deferred financing costs and net debt premium, cash and cash equivalents and restricted cash deposits held for the benefit of lenders provides an estimate of the net contractual amount of borrowed capital to be repaid, which we believe is a beneficial disclosure to investors and analysts. Adjusted Debt to Annualized Adjusted EBITDA Adjusted Debt to Annualized Adjusted EBITDA, or leverage, is a supplemental non-GAAP financial measure we use to evaluate the level of borrowed capital being used to increase the potential return of our real estate investments. We calculate leverage by dividing Adjusted Debt by Annualized Adjusted EBITDA. Because our portfolio growth level is significant to the overall size of the Company, we believe that presenting this leverage metric on a run rate basis is more meaningful than presenting the metric for the historical quarterly period, and we refer to this metric as Adjusted Debt to Annualized Adjusted EBITDA—Current Estimated Run Rate. Leverage should be considered as a supplemental measure of the level of risk to which stockholder value may be exposed. Our computation of leverage may differ from the methodology employed by other companies and, therefore, may not be comparable to other measures.   | appendix | 

 50  Footnotes  Page 41 Reflects the percentage of our contracts that have a STORE Score that is investment grade. We measure the credit quality of our portfolio on a contract-by-contract basis using the STORE Score, which is a proprietary risk measure reflective of both the credit risk of our tenants and the profitability of the operations at the properties.Page 51 Based on percentage growth of our investment portfolio for the year ended December 31, 2016.Page 81 Excludes customers, representing approximately 3.7% of annualized base rent and interest, that do not report corporate revenues. 2 Represents percentage change in reported corporate revenues for the six-month period ended June 30, 2017 as compared to the same period in 2016. Page 101 Free cash flow approximates Adjusted Funds from Operations less dividends paid.2 Represents the weighted average interest rate on balloon payments due in the respective years.Page 11:1 Based on average of ratios of Realty Income and National Retail Properties as of June 30, 2017.2 In addition to improved unencumbered asset ratios, unsecured lenders additionally benefit from the support of significant cash flows after debt service from assets subject to secured borrowings as well as a growing pool of unencumbered BBB rated Master Funding notes.3 Ratios as of September 30, 2017; Unencumbered EBITDA based on NOI from Unencumbered Assets less an allocation of general and administrative expenses based on assets.   Page 12: 1 Shown by % of annualized base rent and interest (annualized based on rates in effect on September 30, 2017, for all leases, loans and direct financing receivables in place as of that date). Excludes contracts representing less than 0.2% of annualized base rent and interest where there are no further escalations remaining in the current lease term and there are no extension options. Of our contracts in place as of September 30, 2017, 81% increase based on changes in CPI, 18% increase based on fixed rates in the contract and only 1% do not increase.2 Represents the weighted average annual escalation rate of the entire portfolio as if all escalations occurred annually.  For escalations based on a formula including CPI, assumes the stated fixed percentage in the contract or assumes 1.5% if no fixed percentage is in the contract.  For contracts with no escalations remaining in the current lease term, assumes the escalation in the extension term. 3 Dividend protection refers to the percentage difference between our AFFO per share and our dividend per share. The wider the relative gap between AFFO per share and dividends per share, the greater the implied dividend protection. All dividends are declared at the discretion of our Board of Directors and future dividends will depend upon our actual funds from operations, financial condition and capital requirements, the annual distribution requirements under the REIT provisions of the Code and other factors.4 S|T|O|R|E defines internal growth as the combination of high average lease escalators and a low AFFO payout ratio, which allows us to reinvest a growing amount of free cash flow back into our business. Page 13:* See chart, page 29.     | appendix |   Page 15:1 Our Board of Directors has opted out of provisions of the Maryland Unsolicited Takeover Act (or “MUTA”), the business combination statute, the control share acquisition statute and provisions otherwise granting us the right to adopt a stockholder rights plan and we may not opt back into any of these statutes or provisions without stockholder approval or, in the case of a stockholder rights plan, stockholder ratification within 12 months of adoption of such a plan.Page 16: * Based on annualized base rent and interest.1 Represents the percentage of our lease contracts that were created by S|T|O|R|E or contain preferred contract terms such as unit-level financial reporting, triple-net lease provisions and, when applicable, master lease provisions.2 Weighted average annual lease escalation represents the weighted average annual escalation rate of the entire portfolio as if all escalations occurred annually. For escalations based on a formula including CPI, assumes the stated fixed percentage in the contract orassumes 1.5% if no fixed percentage is in the contract. For contracts with no escalations remaining in the current lease term, assumes the escalation in the extension term. Calculation excludes contracts representing less than 0.2% of annualized base rent and interest where there are no further escalations remaining in the current lease term and there are no extension options.3 S|T|O|R|E defines occupancy as a property being subject to a lease or loan contract. As of September 30, 2017, the Company owned 19 properties that were vacant and not subject to a contract; subsequent to September 30, 2017, eight of these properties were re-leased, one was sold and the Company’s occupancy rate improved from 99.0% to 99.5%. 

 Footnotes    | appendix |   51  4 The number of properties not currently operating but subject to a lease represents the number of our investment locations that have been closed by the tenant but remain subject to a lease.5 The percentage of investment portfolio subject to master leases represents the percentage of the investment portfolio in multiple properties with a single customer subject to master leases. Based on annualized base rent and interest, 83% of the investment portfolio involves multiple properties with a single customer, whether or not subject to a master lease.6 The average investment amount/replacement cost (new) represents the ratio of purchase price to replacement cost (new) at acquisition.7 S|T|O|R|E calculates unit fixed charge coverage ratio generally as the ratio of (i) the unit’s EBITDAR, less a standardized corporate overhead expense based on estimated industry standards, to (ii) the unit’s total fixed charges, which are its lease expense, interest expense and scheduled principal payments on indebtedness. The 4-Wall coverage ratio refers to a unit’s FCCR before taking into account standardized corporate overhead expense.8 The proportion of investment contracts rated investment grade represents the percentage of our contracts that have a STORE Score that is investment grade. We measure the credit quality of our portfolio on a contract-by-contract basis using the STORE Score, which is a risk measure reflective of both the credit risk of our tenants and the profitability of the operations at the properties.    Page 17: 1 S|T|O|R|E’s pipeline from 2014 through September 30, 2017. See slide 23 for more information about S|T|O|R|E's pipeline, including its composition. S|T|O|R|E may never acquire properties in its pipeline for a variety of reasons as described in the Company’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2016.2 Data as of June 30, 2017.3 See footnote 3 to page 12 on page 50.4 S|T|O|R|E defines occupancy as a property being subject to a lease or loan contract. Pages 18 and 19: 1 Data as of September 30, 2017 and 2016, by % of annualized base rent and interest (annualized based on rates in effect on September 30, 2017 and 2016, for all leases, loans and direct financing receivables in place as of those dates).Page 20:1 Data based on information available on customer websites, news releases and/or SEC filings.2 Data as of September 30, 2017, by % of annualized base rent and interest (annualized based on rates in effect on September 30, 2017, for all leases, loans and direct financing receivables in place as of that date).Page 21:1 Based on annualized base rent and interest.2 Represents the percentage of our properties that are occupied. See footnote 3 to page 16 on page 50.  Page 22:1 We measure the credit quality of our portfolio on a contract-by-contract basis using the STORE Score, which is a proprietary risk measure reflective of both the credit risk of our tenants and the profitability of the operations at our properties.  The STORE Score is a quantitative measurement of contract risk computed by multiplying tenant default probabilities (using Moody’s RiskCalc) and estimated store closure probabilities (using a simple algorithm we developed thathas closure probabilities ranging from 100% to 10%, depending on unit-level profitability).  Qualitative features can also impact investment risk, such as low property investment amounts, favorabletenant debt capital stacks, the presence of third party guarantors, or other factors.  Such qualitative factors are not included in the STORE Score and may serve to mitigate investment risk even further.Page 23:1 Four period moving average.Page 24:1 Acquisitions represents the total of acquisitions of real estate and investment in loans and direct financing receivables. Dispositions represent the original acquisition cost of real estate sold and loan repayments received in conjunction with real estate sales.2 Refer to pages 43 through 48 for definitions of these non-GAAP financial measures and reconciliation to GAAP net income.3 Gross Rate of Return represents initial cap rate plus weighted average annual lease escalators. Gross returns do not represent the actual returns we may earn on properties.  

 Footnotes      | appendix |   52  Page 25:Source: IBES Thomson Reuters. Data as of February 3, 2017.1 Represents 3-year historical normalized diluted EPS growth of five companies: CME Group Inc., Entergy Corporation, Host Hotels & Resorts, The Southern Company and Welltower Inc.2 Market data as of September 30, 2017; P/E multiple based on Goldman Sachs Research and EPS growth based on Goldman Sachs Research estimates.Page 26:1 See footnote 4 to page 12 on page 50.Page 27:* Based on annualized total returns earned by management’s prior investment vehicles while operating as a public company, compared to annualized total returns on the MSCI US REIT Index during the same periods. The past performance of these investment vehicles is not an indicator of S|T|O|R|E’s future performance, and S|T|O|R|E’s performance may be significantly less favorable than the past performance data included in this presentation. Moreover, some of the past performance data covers periods with economic characteristics and cycles and interest rate environments that are significantly different from those S|T|O|R|E faces today and may face in the future.   Page 30:Source: Green Street Advisors, U.S. Treasury, Company data and with respect to FFCA and Spirit, publicly available SEC company filings¹ Risk for each sector measured as the standard deviation of capitalization rates during the periods of operation of FFCA, Spirit and S|T|O|R|E from January 1994 to December 2016. 2 The Sharpe Ratio measures the ratio of excess returns to risk, using the spread between capitalization or lease rates and the 10-year U.S. Treasury yields to measure excess returns, and using the standard deviation of returns to measure risk. All ratios are calculated using capitalization or lease rate data during which FFCA and Spirit were publicly traded companies and the period since S|T|O|R|E’s inception. The ratio is calculated based on historical data from January 1994 to September 2014, and future returns and risk may not be consistent with this historical data.Page 37:* Original Purchase Price represents STORE’s original acquisition cost of the properties including any related mortgage loans. Sale Proceeds are presented net of selling expenses and include loan repayments received in conjunction with property sales. Page 43:1 See page 48 for discussion regarding use of Funds From Operations and Adjusted Funds from Operations.2 For the third quarter of 2017, includes $2.0 million of accelerated amortization of deferred financing costs related to the prepayment of STORE Master Funding debt.  3 For the third quarter of 2017, includes a $4.6 million charge related to accelerated amortization of lease incentives associated with terminated lease contracts.4 Under the two-class method, earnings attributable to unvested restricted stock are deducted from earnings in the computation of per share amounts where applicable. 

   Investor and Media ContactsFinancial Profiles, Inc.Moira Conlon, 310.622.8220Tricia Ross, 310.622.8226STORECapital@finprofiles.com  Corporate Headquarters8377 East Hartford Drive, Suite 100Scottsdale, Arizona 85255480.256.1100www.STOREcapital.com