Attached files

file filename
8-K - 8-K - CMS ENERGY CORPd280043d8k.htm

Exhibit 99.1

 

LOGO

CMS ENERGY
Exhibit 99.1
CMS LISTED NYSE
Third Quarter 2016 Results & Outlook October 27, 2016
Jackson Generating Station Ludington Pumped Storage Cross Winds ®Energy Park
Among lowest acquisition cost ever Fourth largest in the world #2 in renewable sales in the Great Lakes area


LOGO

CMS ENERGY
This presentation is made as of the date hereof and contains “forward-looking statements” as defined in Rule 3b-6 of the
Securities Exchange Act of 1934, Rule 175 of the Securities Act of 1933, and relevant legal decisions. The forward-looking statements are subject to risks and uncertainties. All forward-looking statements should be considered in the context of the risk and other factors detailed from time to time in CMS Energy’s and Consumers Energy’s Securities and Exchange Commission filings. Forward-looking statements should be read in conjunction with “FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS AND
INFORMATION” and “RISK FACTORS” sections of CMS Energy’s and Consumers Energy’s Form 10-K for the year ended
December 31, 2015 and as updated in subsequent 10-Qs. CMS Energy’s and Consumers Energy’s “FORWARD-LOOKING
STATEMENTS AND INFORMATION” and “RISK FACTORS” sections are incorporated herein by reference and discuss important factors that could cause CMS Energy’s and Consumers Energy’s results to differ materially from those anticipated in such statements. CMS Energy and Consumers Energy undertake no obligation to update any of the information presented herein to reflect facts, events or circumstances after the date hereof.
The presentation also includes non-GAAP measures when describing CMS Energy’s results of operations and financial performance. A reconciliation of each of these measures to the most directly comparable GAAP measure is included in the appendix and posted on our website at www.cmsenergy.com.
CMS Energy provides historical financial results on both a reported (GAAP) and adjusted (non-GAAP) basis and provides forward-looking guidance on an adjusted basis. Adjustments could include items such as discontinued operations, asset sales, impairments, restructuring costs, regulatory items from prior years, or other items. Management views adjusted earnings as a key measure of the company’s present operating financial performance and uses adjusted earnings for external communications with analysts and investors. Internally, the company uses adjusted earnings to measure and assess performance. Because the company is not able to estimate the impact of specific line items, which have the potential to significantly impact, favorably or unfavorably, the company’s reported earnings in future periods, the company is not providing reported earnings guidance nor is it providing a reconciliation for the comparable future period earnings. The adjusted earnings should be considered supplemental information to assist in fully understanding our business results, rather than as a substitute for the reported earnings.
Investors and others should note that CMS Energy routinely posts important information on its website and considers the Investor Relations section, www.cmsenergy.com/investor-relations, a channel of distribution.
1


LOGO

Agenda CMS ENERGY
Overview Patti Poppe
Earnings Update President & CEO
The Consumers Energy Way
Unique Model
Financial Results & Outlook Tom Webb
Third Quarter; Full Year Executive VP & CFO
Customer Reinvestment
Sensitivities and Targets
2


LOGO

EPSa Adjusted Results and Guidance.
CMS ENERGY
First Nine Months:
• at $1.73, up 22¢ from 2015
2016 Full-Year guidance raised:
• to $2.00 - $2.02, up 6% to 7%
2017 Full-Year guidance introduced:
• at $2.13 to $2.17, up 6% to 8%
Future long-term annual growth:
• at 6% to 8%
a Adjusted EPS (non-GAAP) Results and Guidance
. . . . raised.
3


LOGO

The Consumers Energy Way CMS ENERGY
The CE Way
Safety . Quality . Cost . Delivery
CUSTOMER FOCUS
ENABLED EMPLOYEES
BUSINESS RESULTS
CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT
STANDARDIZED PROCESSES
Safety: Every day is a safe day
Quality: We get it right the first time
Cost: We see and eliminate waste
Delivery: We get it done on time
. . . . a culture of continuous improvement.
4


LOGO

Simple, Perhaps Unique Model . . . .
CMS ENERGY
2017+
Plan
Capital investment (reliability, costs, enviro mandates)
6% - 8%
Self Funding:
- O&M cost reductions
2 - 3 pts
- Sales growth
1
- No “block” equity dilution & other
2
INVESTMENT SELF-FUNDED
5 - 6 pts
Base rate increase at or below inflation
<2%
. . . . continues to drive sustainable growth, with upside opportunities.
5


LOGO

Next 10 Years -- $17 Billion Investment . . . .
CMS ENERGY
Electric Dist.
Gas
Supply
Opportunity
$6.5 bil
$6.2 bil
$4.3 bil
$3 - $4 bil
Maintenance
Pipeline Deliverability
Environmental
Gas Infrastructure
Electric Reliability
Compression
Clean Energy
More Renewables
Capacity
Replacement Opportunity
Grid Technology
Distribution
Ludington Pumped Storage
Capex Plan
Last to Next 10 years
36% 38%
27% 37%
37% 25%
Up 51%
Up 88%
Down 2%
….with no “big bets” and opportunities to grow.
6


LOGO

O&M Cost Performance . . . .
CMS ENERGY
Actual Cost Reduction
(2015 over 2006)
Peer Average ~5%
Consumers
-2.7%
Source: SNL, Form 1, Electric Non-fuel O&M
New Cost Savings
2014 & 2015
2016 & 2017
Good Business Decisions
(mils)
(mils)
• Attrition (VSP)
$ - 35
$ - 35
• Productivity (Coal Gas)
- 35
- 15
• “Pole Top” Hardening
- 20
- 10
• Smart Meters
- 5
- 20
“Consumers Energy Way”
• Work Management & Eliminate Waste
- 15
- 10
Increases
• Mortality Tables & Discount Rates
+50
0
• Service Upgrades
+20
+ 30
Net savings
$ - 40
$ - 60
Percent savings
- 4%
- 6%
3%
a year!
. . . . driven by good “business decisions” and The “Consumers Energy Way.”
7


LOGO

Michigan. . . .    CMS ENERGY

Grand Rapids
Michigan ranked #1 most competitive Midwest state for job creation by Site Selection Magazine
Michigan ranked #7 best state to do business by CNBC
(improved from #22 in 2015!)
Grand Rapids named best city in the U.S. to invest in housing by Forbes
Grand Rapids ranked #2 best U.S. city to start a business in 2015 by Bplans.com
Grand Rapids ranked third best in USA for job creation & economic development by Area Development Magazine

Economic Indicators    Grand
Rapids
   Michigan    U.S.
Building Permits (‘10 to ‘15)    +242%    +205%    +97%
GDP (‘10 to ’15)    23    14    12
Population (‘10 to ’15)    5     12    4
Unemployment (8/16)    3    4 12    5

. . . . our service territory outperforms.
8


LOGO

Fourth Quarter Outlook . . . .    CMS ENERGY

Maximize customer reinvestments
Deliver high end of EPS range
Constructive partnerships
Performance is Power
. . . . focus remains on customers AND investors.
9


LOGO

2016 Nine Months Adjusted EPS a . . . .
CMS ENERGY
Results
2015
2016
EPS -- (GAAP)
$1.51
$1.70
Voluntary Separation
--
0.03
Program Adjustment
Adjusted (non-GAAP)
$1.51
$1.73
+22¢
Weather-normalized
$1.39
$1.71
+23%
Third Quarter
EPS – GAAP
53¢
67¢
VSP Adjustment
--
3
Adjusted non-GAAP
53¢
70¢
First Call
+17¢
62¢
a Adjusted EPS (non-GAAP)
By Business Segment
EPS
Better
Actual
than Plan
Utility
$1.81
$0.23
Enterprises
0.06
0.02
Interest & other
(0.14)
0.04
Company
$1.73
$0.29
Above Plan
+20%
. . . . substantially stronger than plan.
10


LOGO

2016 EPS a . . . .    CMS ENERGY
  Year-
to-
Date
      Three
Months To
Go
  
  +22¢       (11)¢ to (9)¢   
           $2.00
-
$2.02
  32¢     13¢      +6%
to
+7%
$1.89     (10)¢     (24)¢ - (22)¢   
YTD            YTD
$1.51            $1.73
2015   Cost
&
Other
  Weather   Normal
Weather
  Reinvestment    2016
        Costs &
Other
  

a Adjusted EPS (non-GAAP)
. . . . now guiding to the high end.
11


LOGO

2016 EPS Outlook . . . .    CMS ENERGY
Adjusted EPS                        
(non-GAAP)                        
            Warm            
            Summer            
                     Mild   
                     October   
                  Non-      
                  weather      
                       
            Weather             +6% to
+7%
            14¢            
   Weather
&
      Recovery               
   Storms          Pension
“Yield
Curve”
         Choices   
            Enhanced
Capitalization
   3       2017 “Pull
Aheads”
  
            ‘15 Pension
Contribution
   2       Debt Pre-
funding
   5
            Improved
“UAs” &
Other
   3       Foundation
& Low
Income
   4
            Offsets    13¢       Operations
and
Quality
   4
                     Choices    15¢
      (13)¢                  
January       March 31       June 30       September 30    Today    December

. . . . in a good position to meet high end.
12


LOGO

Managing Work Every Year . . . .
CMS ENERGY
a
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
EPS
Mild
$2.00
Summer
+18¢
+17¢
Cost
+7%
productivity
above plan
1.80
+7%
Offsets
Reinvestment
+13¢
+7¢
-13¢
Reinvestment
Hot
+7%
1.60
Summer
Winter Mild
RECORD
Hot
WARM
+7%
Cost
Summer
-9¢
productivity
+7%
Reinvestment
above plan
1.40
Cost
“Summerless”
Hot
Productivity
Summer
+7%
Summer
Mild Summer
+7%
Storms
-13¢
2013 – 2015
1.20
+7%
Customer Reinvestment =
Cost
$238 million
productivity
Cost
Cost
0
productivity
productivity
a Adjusted EPS (non-GAAP)
. . . . maximizes benefits for customers AND investors.
13


LOGO

“DIG” (750 MW) & Peakers (200 MW)    CMS ENERGY
Pre-Tax Income                  Opportunities     
(mils)              
$80                       $75
   Contracts           
   (layering
in over
time)
          
           $55    +$40
           +$20   
40             $35          
        New      
     $20    contracts      
     $12                   
   Outage           
   pull-ahead           
0                        
   2015   2016    2017    Future   
Capacity ($/kw-mth)    $1.00    $2.00    $3.00    $4.50    $7.50
Available:               
• Energy    0%    0%    0%       25%
• Capacity    0    0    10       50% - 90%

. . . . adding value.
14


LOGO

2016 Sensitivities    CMS ENERGY
      2016    Impact
   Sensitivity    EPS    OCF
• Sales a          (mils)
• Electric (37,500 GWh)    ± 1%    ± $0.05    ± $ 20
• Gas (309 Bcf)    ± 2    ± 0.03    ± 15
• Gas prices (NYMEX)    ± 50¢    + – 0    + – 55
• ROE         
• Electric (10.3%)    ± 10 bps    ± 0.01    ± 5
• Gas (10.3%)    ± 20    ± 0.01    ± 4
• Interest Rates    ±100 bps    ± < 0.01    ± 5
• Capital Investment    +$100 mil    + 0.01    + 10
• Law Update    Customer upside    Not In Plan   

a Reflect 2016 sales forecast; weather normalized
. . . . reflect strong risk mitigation.
15


LOGO

Financial Targets    CMS ENERGY
   2016    2017
Adjusted EPS (non-GAAP)    $2.00 -
$2.02
   $2.13 -
$2.17
   +6% to
+7%
   +6%
to
+8%
Operating cash flow (mils)    $1,550    $1,650
Dividend payout ratio    ³ 62%    ³ 62%
Customer price incr./(decr.)      
Electric (excl. fuel)    ~1%    ~2%
Gas    ~(10)%    ~2%
FFO/Average debt    18%    18 12%
Capital investment (bils)    $1.7    $1.7

. . . . fifteenth year of transparent, consistent, strong high-end performance.
16


LOGO

Consistent Growth Through    CMS ENERGY
         7% CAGR            
      EPSa       Dividend       5% to 7%    6% to 8%
               Weather      
Recession          Recession       Help      
               Hurt      
   a Adjusted EPS (non-GAAP)                  
2003   2004   2005   2006   2007   2008   2009   2010   2011   2012   2013   2014   2015   2016   2017
Cold   Mild   Hot   Warm   Mild   Cold   Summer-   Hot   Hot   Warm   Mild   Polar   Cold Feb.   Warm  
winter   summer   summer   winter   summer   winter   “less”   summer   summer   winter   summer   vortex   Warm Dec.   Winter  
    Governor (D)             Governor (R)            
Commission (D)       Commission (D)     Commission (R)     Commission (I)              
Whipple       Joos           Russell       Poppe      

. . . . recessions, adverse weather, and leadership changes. 17


LOGO

CMS ENERGY
Q & A
See you at EEI
18


LOGO

Appendix


LOGO

Operating Cash Flow    CMS ENERGY
Amount                      Up
$0.7
(bils)    Gross
operating
cash flowa
                  Billion
   up > $0.1
billion per
year
                 
$2.9                     
2.4                $2.5    $2.7    $2.8
      $2.1    $2.2    $2.4    Interest,
working
     
   $1.9             Capital
and
taxes
     
1.9                     
      $1.55               
1.4          Operating
cash flow
           
0.9    Investment                  
0.4                     
(0.2)                     
         Cash    flow
before
dividend
        
(0.7)    a Non-
GAAP
                 
   2015    2016    2017    2018    2019    2020    2021
NOLs & Credits    $0.7    $0.9    $0.8    $0.7    $0.4    $0.3    $0.1

. . . . up $0.7 billion or 34% over five years.
20


LOGO

Liquidity (as of September 2016) . . . .    CMS ENERGY
   Renewal    Capacity       Availability   
      $1.9 Billion         
CMS Energy             $1.7 Billion    Stronger
               liquidity
5-year revolver    May 2021    $550 mils          than peers
            $549 mils   
Consumers Energy               
5-year revolver    May 2021    650         
Letter of Credit    Apr 2018          568   
Letter of Credit    Aug 2018       68      
Letter of Credit    May 2018       36      
         30      
2-year revolver    Nov 2017    250       250   
Cash       339       339   

. . . . strong and conservative.
21


LOGO

2016 Cash Flow Forecast (non-GAAP)    CMS ENERGY

CMS Energy Parent

Cash at year end 2015 Sources Consumers Energy dividend and tax sharing Enterprises Sources Uses Interest and preferred dividend Overhead and Federal tax payments Equity infusion Pension contribution Uses a Cash flow Financing and Dividend New issues Retirements DRP, continuous equity Net short-term financing & other Common dividend Financing Cash at year end 2016 Bank Facility ($550) available    $159 $503 38 $541 $(146) (25) (275) 0 $(446) $95 $575 (500)— 72 (29) (346) $(228) $26 $549

a Includes other
Consumers Energy

Cash at year end 2015 Sources Operating (depreciation & amortization $800) Other working capital Sources Uses Interest and preferred dividend Capital expenditures b Dividend and tax sharing $0 to CMS Pension contribution Uses Cash flow Financing Equity New issues Retirements Net short-term financing & other Financing Cash at year end 2016 Facilities ($900)    Amount (mils) $50 $2,064 (199) $1,865 $(255) (1,723) (503) 0 $(2,481) $(616) $275 450 (173) 39 $591 $25 $568

b Includes cost of removal and capital leases
22


LOGO

GAAP Reconciliation


LOGO

CMS ENERGY
CMS ENERGY CORPORATION
Earnings Per Share By Year GAAP Reconciliation (Unaudited)

   2003    2004    2005    2006    2007    2008    2009    2010    2011    2012    2013    2014    2015
Reported earnings (loss) per share - GAAP    ($0.30)    $0.64    ($0.44)    ($0.41)    ($1.02)    $1.20    $0.91    $1.28    $1.58    $1.42    $1.66    $1.74    $1.89
Pretax items:                                       
Electric and gas utility    0.32    (0.60)    —      —      (0.06)    0.08    0.55    0.05    —      0.27    —      —      —  
Tax impact    (0.11)    0.21    —      —      (0.01)    (0.03)    (0.22)    (0.02)    —      (0.10)    —      —      —  
Enterprises    0.93    0.97    0.06    (0.12)    1.67    (0.02)    0.14    (0.05)*       (0.01)*       0.05*   
Tax impact    (0.19)    (0.35)    (0.02)    0.10    (0.42)*       (0.05)    0.02    (0.11)*       (*)    (0.02)    (*)
Corporate interest and other    0.25    (0.06)    0.06    0.45    0.17    0.01    0.01*       -*       *    *    *
Tax impact    (0.09)    0.03    (0.02)    (0.18)    (0.49)    (0.03)    (*)    (*)    (0.01)    (*)    (*)    (*)    (*)
Discontinued operations (income) loss, net    (0.16)    0.02    (0.07)    (0.03)    0.40    (*)    (0.08)    0.08    (0.01)    (0.03)*       (*)    (*)
Asset impairment charges    —      —      2.80    1.07    0.93    —      —      —      —      —      —      —      —  
Tax impact    —      —      (0.98)    (0.31)    (0.33)    —      —      —      —      —      —      —      —  
Cumulative accounting changes    0.25    0.02    —      —      —      —      —      —      —      —      —      —      —  
Tax impact    (0.09)    (0.01)    —      —      —      —      —      —      —      —      —      —      —  
Adjusted earnings per share, including MTM - non-GAAP    $0.81    $0.87    $1.39    $0.57    $0.84    $1.21
(a)
   $1.26    $1.36    $1.45    $1.55    $1.66    $1.77    $1.89
Mark-to-market       0.04    (0.65)    0.80                           
Tax impact       (0.01)    0.22    (0.29)                           
Adjusted earnings per share, excluding MTM - non-GAAP    NA    $0.90    $0.96    $1.08    NA    NA    NA    NA    NA    NA    NA    NA    NA

* Less than $0.01 per share.
(a) $1.25 excluding discontinued Exeter operations and accounting changes related to convertible debt and restricted stock.
24


LOGO

CMS ENERGY
CMS ENERGY CORPORATION
Earnings Segment Results GAAP Reconciliation (Unaudited)
Three Months Ended Nine Months Ended
September 30 2016 2015 2016 2015
Electric Utility
Reported $0.69 $0.60 $1.42 $1.24
Downsizing Program 0.03 —   0.03 —  
Tax Impact (0.01) —   (0.01) —  
Restructuring Costs and Other —   —   —   —  
Adjusted $0.71 $0.60 $1.44 $1.24
Gas Utility
Reported $0.01 $(0.02) $0.36 $0.41
Downsizing Program 0.01 —   0.01 —  
Tax Impact (*) —   (*) —  
Restructuring Costs and Other —   —   —   —  
Adjusted $0.02 $(0.02) $0.37 $0.41
Enterprises
Reported $0.03 $0.01 $0.06 $0.04
Downsizing Program * -* —  
Restructuring Costs and Other * * * *
Adjusted $0.03 $0.01 $0.06 $0.04
Corporate Interest and Other
Reported $(0.06) $(0.06) $(0.14) $(0.18)
Restructuring Costs and Other * * * *
Adjusted $(0.06) $(0.06) $(0.14) $(0.18)
Discontinued Operations
Reported $* $* $(*) $*
Discontinued Operations (Income) Loss (*) (*)* (*)
Adjusted $—   $—   $—   $—  
Totals
Reported $0.67 $0.53 $1.70 $1.51
Discontinued Operations (Income) Loss (*) (*)* (*)
Downsizing Program 0.04 —   0.04 —  
Tax Impact (0.01) —   (0.01) —  
Restructuring Costs and Other * * * *
Adjusted $0.70 $0.53 $1.73 $1.51
Average Common Shares Outstanding - Diluted (in millions) 279.2 276.9 278.8 276.3
* Less than $0.01 per share.
25


LOGO

CMS ENERGY
CMS ENERGY CORPORATION EBITDA GAAP Reconciliation
12 Months Ended (Unaudited)

in millions    09/30/16    12/31/15    09/30/15
Reported earnings - GAAP    $580    $523    $513
Interest on long-term debt    404    386    387
Other interest expense    16    14    25
Allowance for borrowed funds used during construction    (5)    (4)    (3)
Income tax expense    287    271    266
Income attributable to noncontrolling interests    2    2    2
Downsizing program (pretax)    11    —      —  
Restructuring costs and other (pretax)    2    —      —  
EBIT - Adjusted (1)    1,297    1,192    1,190
Depreciation and amortization    783    750    746
EBITDA - Adjusted (1)    $2,080    $1,942    $1,936

(1) Adjusted (Non-GAAP)
26


LOGO

CMS ENERGY
CONSUMERS ENERGY COMPANY EBITDA GAAP Reconciliation
12 Months Ended (Unaudited)

in millions    9/30/2016    12/31/15    9/30/2015
Reported earnings - GAAP    $632    $592    $575
Interest on long-term debt    259    252    251
Other interest expense    —      2    13
Allowance for borrowed funds used during construction    (5)    (4)    (3)
Income tax expense    319    302    302
Preferred stock dividends    2    2    2
Downsizing program (pretax)    11    —      —  
EBIT - Adjusted (1)    1,218    1,146    1,140
Depreciation and amortization    776    744    740
EBITDA - Adjusted (1)    $1,994    $1,890    $1,880

(1) Adjusted (Non-GAAP)
27


LOGO

CMS ENERGY
Consumers Energy
2016 Forecasted Cash Flow GAAP Reconciliation (in millions) (unaudited)
Reclassifications From Sources and Uses to Statement of Cash Flows
Interest/ Capital
Presentation Sources and Uses Tax Other Financing Lease Pymts Securitization Common Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows
non-GAAP Sharing Payments and Other Debt Pymts Dividends GAAP
Description Amount Operating as Operating as Financing as Financing as Financing Amount Description
Cash at year end 2015 $50 $—   $—   $—   $—   $—   $50 Cash at year end 2015
Sources
Operating (dep & amort $805) $2,064
Other working capital (199) Net cash provided by
Sources $1,865 $—   $(255) $25 $25 $—   $1,660 operating activities
Uses
Interest and preferred dividends $(255)
Capital expenditures a (1,723)
Dividends/tax sharing to CMS (503)
Pension Contribution —   —   Net cash used in
Uses $(2,481) $—   $255 $—   $—   $503 $(1,723) investing activities
Cash flow from
Cash flow $(616) $—   $—   $25 $25 $503 $(63) operating and
investing activities
Financing
Equity $275
New Issues 450
Retirements (173)
Net short-term financing & other 39 —   —   Net cash provided by
Financing $591 $—   $—   $(25) $(25) $(503) $38 financing activities
Net change in cash $(25) $—   $—   $—   $—   $—   $(25) Net change in cash
Cash at year end 2016 $25 $—   $—   $—   $—   $—   $25 Cash at year end 2016
a Includes cost of removal and capital leases
28


LOGO

CMS ENERGY
CMS Energy Parent
2016 Forecasted Cash Flow GAAP Reconciliation (in millions) (unaudited)
Reclassifications From Sources and Uses to Statement of Cash Flows
Presentation Sources and Uses Non Equity Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows
non-GAAP Uses GAAP
Description Amount as Operating Other Amount Description
Cash at year end 2015 $159 $—   $(159) $—   Cash at year end 2015
Sources
Consumers Energy dividends/tax sharing $503
Enterprises 38 Net cash provided by
Sources $541 $(171) $—   $370 operating activities
Uses
Interest and preferred dividends $(146)
Overhead and Federal tax payments (25)
Equity infusions (275)
Pension Contribution —   Net cash used in
Uses (a) $(446) $171 $—   $(275) investing activities
Cash flow from
Cash flow $95 $—   $—   $95 operating and
investing activities
Financing and dividends
New Issues $575
Retirements (500)
Equity programs (DRP, continuous equity) 72
Net short-term financing & other (29) —   —  
Common dividend (346) Net cash used in
Financing $(228) $—   $133 $(95) financing activities
Net change in cash $(133) $—   $133 $—   Net change in cash
Cash at year end 2016 $26 $—   $(26) $—   Cash at year end 2016
(a) Includes other
29


LOGO

CMS ENERGY
Consolidated CMS Energy
2016 Forecasted Consolidation of Consumers Energy and CMS Energy Parent Statements of Cash Flow (in millions) (unaudited)

         Eliminations/ Reclassifications/ Consolidation to Arrive at         
         the Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows         
Statements of Cash Flows    Other    Consumers    Equity      
   Consumers    CMS
Parent
   Consolidated    Common
Dividend
   Infusions
to
   Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows
Description    Amount    Amount    Entities    as
Financing
   Consumers    Amount    Description
Cash at year end 2015    $50    $—      $216    $—      $—      $266    Cash at
year end
2015
Net cash provided by    $1,660    $370    $23    $(503)    $—      $1,550    Net cash
provided
by
operating activities                      operating
activities
Net cash used in    (1,723)    (275)    (136)    —      275    (1,859)    Net cash
used in
investing activities                      investing
activities
Cash flow from    $(63)    $95    $(113)    $(503)    $275    $(309)    Cash flow
from
operating and                      operating
and
investing activities                      investing
activities
Net cash provided by (used in)    $38    $(95)    $(13)    $503    $(275)    $158    Net cash
provided
by
financing activities                      financing
activities
Net change in cash    $(25)    $—      $(126)    $—      $—      $(151)    Net change
in cash
Cash at year end 2016    $25    $—      $90    $—      $—      $115    Cash at
year end
2016

30


LOGO

CMS ENERGY
CMS Energy
Reconciliation of Gross Operating Cash Flow to GAAP Operating Activities
(unaudited)
(mils)

   2014    2015    2016    2017    2018    2019    2020    2021
Consumers Operating Income + Depreciation & Amortization    $1,813    $1,866    $2,064    $2,150    $2,356    $2,520    $2,637    $2,783
Enterprises Project Cash Flows    20    20    38    54    52    52    54    55
Gross Operating Cash Flow    $1,833    $1,886    $2,102    $2,204    $2,408    $2,572    $2,691    $2,838
Other operating activities including taxes, interest payments and                        
working capital    (386)    (246)    (552)    (554)    (658)    (722)    (741)    (788)
Net cash provided by operating activities    $1,447    $1,640    $1,550    $1,650    $1,750    $1,850    $1,950    $2,050

31